§ 4-33. Banks' right of recourse when someone else caused the loss

Finansavtaleloven·LOV-2020-12-18-146

Machine-translated from Norwegian. The Norwegian text is the one that applies. Read the original in Norwegian.Norsk English العربية Polski Українська

In brief

The text of the law (unofficial translation)

§ 4-33. The service provider's right to compensation for outlays etc.

(1) If a payment service provider (betalingstjenesteyter) has covered a loss under the rules in § 4-28 or § 4-32, and the loss is due to circumstances on the part of another payment service provider or an intermediary, the party who caused the loss shall compensate the outlay and the loss incurred by the payment service provider.
(2) If the payment initiation service provider is responsible for a payment transaction (betalingstransaksjon) that is not executed correctly, the payment initiation service provider shall, immediately on request from the account provider (kontotilbyder), compensate the loss that has arisen, including losses arising because a payment service provider has failed to use strong customer authentication (sterk kundeautentisering), and the refund amount under § 4-28 fifth paragraph.
(3) Losses resulting from another payment service provider or an intermediary not using strong customer authentication may be claimed by the payment service provider that has covered the loss.
(4) A payment service provider cannot be held liable for financial loss under the first to third paragraphs that is caused by unusual circumstances beyond its control, and whose consequences the service provider (tjenesteyter) could not reasonably have foreseen or avoided. The same applies to losses caused by the payment service provider being bound by other obligations under or pursuant to law.
(5) The rules in this section do not limit a payment service provider's right of recourse under § 2-16 or to compensation under otherwise applicable rules.
Source: Lovdata — Finansavtaleloven (the Financial Contracts Act) § 4-33

What does this mean?

This section governs the settlement between the parties in the payment chain after the customer (kunde) has received their money. If a bank has covered a loss under § 4-28 or § 4-32, and the cause lies with another bank or an intermediary, the bank can demand that the party who caused it cover the outlay and the loss.

The second paragraph is aimed at payment initiation service providers. If the payment initiation service provider is responsible for a payment that was not executed correctly, it must immediately compensate the loss when the account provider asks for it. This also covers losses resulting from a bank not using strong customer authentication, and the amount the account provider has had to refund under § 4-28 fifth paragraph. The third paragraph says something similar about strong customer authentication: Losses resulting from another bank or an intermediary not using it can be claimed by the bank that covered the loss.

The fourth paragraph provides two exceptions from liability. The bank is not liable for financial loss caused by unusual circumstances beyond its control, whose consequences it could not reasonably have foreseen or avoided. Nor is it liable when the loss results from the bank being bound by other obligations under or pursuant to law.

The fifth paragraph says that the rules in the section do not take away the bank's right of recourse under § 2-16 or its right to compensation under other rules. Recourse means seeking to recover an outlay. Under § 2-16, a person who has fulfilled someone else's monetary obligation can immediately demand that the debtor (skyldner) cover the outlay. If several parties are jointly and severally liable (each can be required to pay the full amount), the one who has paid can claim reimbursement from the others. The provision can be departed from by agreement, unless otherwise provided.

This section sits at the end of the series of liability rules. The bank's liability for transactions initiated by the payer (betaler) follows from § 4-28, and for those initiated by the payee (betalingsmottaker), from § 4-29. Liability for unauthorised transactions is set out in § 4-30, and reduction of the customer's liability in § 4-31. Refunds when the customer disputes liability are set out in § 4-32. The titles of § 4-47 and § 8-2 show that the rules on geographical scope and the transitional rules also affect this section.

Related sections
All sections of the Financial Contracts Act →